Should login screens have email or email address?
Jim Barrow
vrfour at verizon.net
Thu Sep 21 11:36:00 MDT 2006
>>Richard Combs wrote:
>Raj Nair wrote:
>>On many login screens of websites and software I had found
>>the 'email' field, which asks you to enter your email address
>>to login.
>
>>I think the world email is incorrect. Instead, it should be
>>email address or email ID at least. I did discuss this with
>>my technical editor, but to no avail. 'This usage is common'
>>was the reply I got. Any comments?
>Yes, three:
>1) If you've seen it on "many login screens," then that confirms >that your editor is correct, doesn't it? And if it's common, then
>most >of us have seen it many times and understand it >immediately.
>2) Adding the word "address" neither hurts nor helps; adding "ID" >is a really bad idea because most of us have never encountered the >phrase "email ID" and may be a bit confused by it.
>3) If I were you, I wouldn't give my boss the idea that I have so >little to do that I can obsess over such a trivial matter. :-)
I've actually had a little fun with situations like these in the past. Whenever I need to include instructions/screenshots that need to include email addresses/login IDs etc., I change these so that my identifying information is not displayed. Instead, I use "dummy" IDs that reflect the company that I'm working for.
When I worked for the Mouse House I would use IDs such as these: MMouse at Disney.com or Minnie123!, so long as the dummy IDs that I created used the correct naming convention.
- Jim
More information about the TECHWR-L
mailing list