Re: Another tragic case of not reading the manual

Subject: Re: Another tragic case of not reading the manual
From: "Chuck Martin" <cm -at- writeforyou -dot- com>
To: techwr-l
Date: Thu, 14 Aug 2003 10:19:49 -0700

Certainly it is sad to read about such a tragedy, but from what I can
discern from the text here, the real problem isn' that the manual laid
unread, but that the design of the hardware apparently didn't make clear
that such an "access panel" existed.

If one was built in, designers presumably knew that people could and would
go inside. That it was not clearly marked, both inside and out, to be easily
findable is a flaw in design, not a failure to read.

Saying that this happened because the users didn't read the manual is
blaming the user for the event, a very wrong but utterly common attitude.

Conceptually, the design of the machine, or at least one part of it, failed
to communicate both its existence and its use.

Chuck Martin

<miriam -at- silvershed -dot- co -dot- uk> wrote in message news:209230 -at- techwr-l -dot- -dot- -dot-
> Just read this in the Guardian (a UK newspaper).
> We discussed aeronautical instances of not using a manual a while ago -
> this is a much more humble example of what goes wrong, isn't it. And yet,
> in its own way, equally tragic.
> I wonder how far we can go as authors to make sure that this doesn't
> happen - it seems like the manual could have been the most shining example
> of technical authorship, and it still wouldn't have helped.
> A laundry worker died of heat exhaustion after climbing into a giant
> industrial washing machine to free some sheets and getting stuck, an
> inquest heard yesterday.
<the rest of the story snipped>

Previous by Author: Re: FrameMaker > Help > FrameMaker?
Next by Author: Re: Creating Microsoft Word template - How do I prompt for information?
Previous by Thread: Re: Another tragic case of not reading the manual
Next by Thread: RE: Another tragic case of not reading the manual

What this post helpful? Share it with friends and colleagues:

Sponsored Ads